by Casper and Nectar are popular among all mattresses for two very different reasons. Casper gives you a choice between choosing an all-foam and hybrid version of their original mattress (check the top rated mattresses). At the same time, Nectar is budget-friendly with industry-leading after-sales services that ensure the best bag for your buck.
But the question is should you go for the Casper Original’s customized offering tailored to your sleep needs, or would you consider going for the best value for your money?
We will find all about it in this ultimate showdown between Casper and Nectar.
Comparison Table – Casper Vs. Nectar
| Casper Mattress | Nectar Mattress | |
| Best for | All body types and sleep positions | Hot and combination sleepers |
| Trial Period | 100 nights | 365 nights |
| Warranty | 10 years | Lifetime |
| Price range | $895 – $1895 | $399 – $1138 |
The Key Differences – Casper Vs. Nectar
Who The Casper Is Best For:
Best for…
All sleep positions: One of the best features of the Casper Original mattress is that it is designed for all sleep positions. If you prefer to sleep on your side or back, you should consider the all-foam variant. And if you prefer to sleep on your belly, then the hybrid variant is better. And both these mattresses work for combination sleepers too.
All body types: As this mattress comes in two variants, the all-foam, and hybrid, all body types can benefit from this mattress, whether you are a regular body type or a plus-size sleeper.
Going all-foam or hybrid: This mattress is available in both all-foam and hybrid versions. It means that you can conveniently choose between the two based on your sleep preferences. Both these types have their pros and cons.
May not be best for…
Price: Casper Original Mattress comes with a hefty price tag. Now, there are other options available as well in this price range with more options and benefits.
Warranty and sleep trial: As we have just mentioned, at this price, there are other brands that offer some customization options with longer sleep trials and warranties.
Who The Nectar Is Best For:
Best for…
Combination sleepers: Being a memory foam mattress, Nectar is a good option if you don’t have strict preferences to sleep in a particular position. It works well for combination sleepers who tend to sleep on their sides, backs, and bellies throughout the night.
Those who tend to sleep hot: The top layer of this mattress has gel-infused memory foam, and it’s designed to dissipate heat effectively. So it works well for hot sleepers. It might not be better than latex, hybrid, or innerspring mattress. But it still gets the job done.
Excellent conformance: Do you like that hugging feel on your sleep surface? Well, it’s good news for you because Nectar Mattress comes with that precise feeling you love.
May not be best for…
Heavyweight sleepers: As this mattress conforms well and is softer, it doesn’t work well for a plus-sized sleeper (check 10 amazing mattresses for overweight people). The mattress itself will deteriorate, and the sleeper will develop lower back pain due to spinal misalignment.
Strict stomach sleepers: If you strictly sleep on your belly, this is not a firmer surface for you to consider because your ships will sag, and your spine will go out of alignment, causing lower back pain.
Top Mattress Features Compared – Casper Vs. Nectar
Construction
The mattress is available in two different versions; all-foam and hybrid. The foam version has Casper’s signature AirScape top layer that makes the surface more breathable, followed by the support layer that has targeted zones to provide pressure relief to your joints. So this mattress works well for you if you sleep on your side or back.
This support layer has different ergonomic sections, letting your body sink slowly into the surface. So you get that enveloping feel from your mattress. And right at the end is the base layer made of durable high-density foam for additional support and to make the mattress more long-lasting.
The hybrid version also has a very similar construction apart from the additional layer of coils within the base layer. With this additional layer, you will get better support and breathability. And if you tend to sleep hot, the hybrid erosion will work better for you
This mattress comes with a top layer featuring a quilted cool cover that has poly-blend to guarantee top-level breathability after that is the comfort layer featuring the Nectar Smart layer that is infused with gel.
It ensures that the sleeper remains comfortable as the heat from their body gets dissipated throughout the night for a comfortable and restful experience (also check the most comfortable mattresses on the market).
Next is the Dynamic Support layer, made of foam in the mattress for support. It also functions as a transition layer between the comfort and base layers right at the bottom.
The base layer of this mattress further provides more support to your body and makes the mattress a long-lasting product. It will also prevent the mattress from slipping underneath.
Firmness
This mattress is available in two different versions and has different firmness configurations. The gel-infused memory foam variant has a medium configuration. In contrast, the hybrid version comes with a medium-firm configuration.
The foam variant will work well for side and back sleepers as it provides the necessary conformance and pressure relief. It will go soft on your shoulders and hips (check the top rated mattresses for shoulder pain) as you sleep on your side and will be supportive enough when you sleep on your back. The main goal here is to provide spinal alignment and joint relief no matter what sleep position you go for.
If you prefer to sleep on your belly or need more support, you should consider going for the hybrid version. With less conformance, this sleep surface will provide you with more support and less hugging feels if you prefer to sleep on your stomach or tend to sleep hot. This surface also works well if you are looking for better spinal alignment (also check great mattresses for scoliosis).
Nectar Mattress is a gel-infused memory foam mattress with a medium-firm configuration. It provides you with a balanced feel of conformance and support.
The gel-infused memory foam right at the top provides a hugging feel. At the same time, the support layers underneath add to your spine’s support when you are resting on your mattress.
This memory foam mattress not only works well for your spinal alignment, but it will also guarantee that you don’t have to deal with joint pains when you sleep on it. The pressure-relieving top layer allows you to sleep on it in different positions while staying comfortable.
But you must remember that if you are a strict stomach sleeper, it might not work for you because your hips will sag, and your spine will go out of shape, causing back pains (also check 10 amazing mattresses for back pain).
Motion Isolation and Edge Support
As the Casper Original Mattress is available in two different variants, you can pick the right option based on your preferences. As with most memory foam mattresses, the all-foam variant is great regarding motion isolation.
It is a suitable option for you if you want to share your mattress with someone who sleeps restlessly. This variant won’t transfer motion from one end to the other, and you can sleep comfortably no matter how much your partner moves at night (check the best selling mattresses for couple).
But memory foams are not that great regarding motion isolation, and the all-foam variant is not different. It will take some time to get back in its original shape and deteriorate over time. It will also provide you with a lesser area coverage on the mattress.
But if edge support is your strongest preference, perhaps you should consider buying the hybrid version. You can maximize the sleep surface area, and the mattress won’t go out of shape either.
However, the hybrid version is not that great regarding motion isolation. You will feel that your partner has had a restless night when you share the mattress. Hybrids are not that great in restricting motion transferability, similar to the Casper Original Hybrid mattress.
Nectar Mattress is infused with gel, but it functions much like a true memory foam mattress. And we all know how good memory foam mattresses are regarding motion isolation.
No matter how restless your sleep partner is at night, you won’t feel it because your mattress restricts the motion from one end to the other. So if that is your main priority, a Nectar mattress is a good choice.
However, foam mattresses are not that great regarding edge support. This is the case with the all-foam variant of Casper Original Mattress, and the same goes with the Nectar Mattress.
So if you are looking for a mattress specifically for edge support, you need to look elsewhere. This mattress is also not very responsive, and you won’t feel the bounce in it like all other memory foam mattresses.
Temperature Regulation
Casper Original Mattress is versatile because it is available in two different versions. The all-foam version is not great when it comes to temperature regulation. Of course, it’s a memory foam mattress. These mattresses are not high performers in dissipating body heat and wicking moisture.
But the hybrid variant is the complete opposite of that. It comes with a coil system that boosts airflow within the mattress, and it will dissipate heat and wick moisture away from the sleep surface, allowing you to rest comfortably. So it works well for hot sleepers. But the same can’t be said for the all-foam version of Casper Original Mattress.
Nectar mattress is a memory foam mattress, and memory foam mattresses are not the ideal options for temperature regulation. You might get that hugging feel from your sleep surface, but if you tend to sleep hot, then this will make you a bit uncomfortable. It might work well in colder climates, though.
However, Nectar has tried to make immense by introducing a gel-infused memory foam layer right at the top of the mattress. It functions well to dissipate heat from your body and wick moisture up to some extent.
If you compare it with a conventional memory foam mattress, you will notice that the gel-infused memory foam does work nicely. Still, it will certainly not outperform a hybrid or a latex mattress in comparison.
Position And Body Type
The thing that makes Casper Original Mattress a highly versatile option is that it is available in two different models. The foam variant is comforting, while the hybrid variant is supportive.
The foam variant is a top choice for side and back sleepers who need more pressure relief. Their hybrid variant is an ideal option for strict stomach sleepers who need additional support (check 10 great mattresses for stomach sleepers).
The all-foam variant is a good choice for most sleepers weighing around 130 to 230 pounds, and you can be closer to the lower spectrum. The hybrid variant is suitable for people who weigh around the higher spectrum.
So Casper provides you with an opportunity to look for the ideal sleep surface according to your body type and the sleep positions you prefer.
Nectar Mattress is a gel-infused memory foam mattress that works well for people who don’t have any strict positions that they prefer to sleep in.
That is why it is an ideal option for combination sleepers. It will also suit most side and back sleepers (also check the best pillows for back sleepers) because it has a medium feel.
But it won’t work for the people who prefer to sleep strictly on their bellies. The mattress’s soft feel will cause your hips to sag, and your spine will go out of its original shape.
This is exactly the reason why it is not an ideal option for heavyweight sleepers as well. If you weigh more than 230 lbs, you need to look for a firmer option for your sleep surface.
Price Range
You will notice that Nectar Mattress is significantly lower priced as compared to Casper Original mattress. And to add to that, Nectar also comes with a lifetime warranty and a 365-night trial. This puts Nectar in the driving seat if you are looking for a budget-friendly option (also check our top 10 best mattresses under $600).
But Casper does a fine job by providing you with an option to either go for an all-foam version or a hybrid version of their mattress. This is something that Nectar doesn’t offer, and it evens out the comparison between Casper and Nectar
| Casper Original | Nectar Mattress | |
| Twin | $895 | $399 |
| Twin XL | $995 | $569 |
| Full | $1195 | $699 |
| Queen | $1295 | $799 |
| King | $1695 | $1099 |
| Cal King | $1695 | $1099 |
| Split King | – | $1138 |
What is the difference between the Casper and Nectar mattress trial periods?
Casper offers a 100 night trial period, while Nectar offers a 365 night trial period. Nectar’s longer trial period gives you more time to evaluate the mattress.
Are Casper or Nectar mattresses good for side sleepers?
Both mattresses can work for side sleepers. The conforming foam layers in both mattresses cushion the shoulders and hips to alleviate pressure points. The Casper foam may provide more targeted relief with its zoned support system. Strict side sleepers may prefer the closer conforming feel of the all-foam Nectar.
Which mattress will likely last longer?
The Nectar mattress may have slightly longer durability than the Casper. It has a thicker comfort layer and high-density base foam. Also, the Nectar has a “Forever Warranty” compared to Casper’s 10 year warranty, showing the company expects a long usable life. However, both use quality foams and should provide many years of use for most sleepers under normal conditions.
Verdict
Both Casper and Nectar are high-quality mattresses. Nectar is the right choice if you want a budget-friendly option. It will also work for you if you are a combination sleeper and prefer that hugging feels on your sleep surface as it is a gel-infused memory foam mattress.
Casper is a top choice if you choose between a hybrid or an all-foam version. However, you have more options to choose from according to your body type and your sleep preferences with Casper, so you will have to pay a bit more to get their mattress.