by Puffy and Purple are two trendy brands on the market today. They are highly regarded for their quality mattresses at reasonable prices (check 10 amazing mattresses under $1,000).
You need to consider various factors before choosing between them because they both have pros and cons. And in this comparison, we will exactly explore which one of them is ideally suited to whom.
So, continue reading till the end and find out which one of these mattresses you should go for based on your sleep preferences (also check 10 great mattresses on the market).
Comparative Table to Choose Between Puffy Mattress and Purple Mattress
| Puffy Mattress | Purple Mattress | |
| Best for | Hot and combination sleepers | Hot and combo sleepers |
| Trial Period | 101 nights | 100 nights |
| Warranty | Lifetime | 10 years |
| Price range | $1449 – $1999 | $799 – $1998 |
The Key Differences Between Puffy and Purple Mattresses
Who The Puffy Mattress Is Best For
Best for…
People who prefer to sleep on their sides and back: If you love to sleep on your side or back, this is the mattress you need in your bedroom. It provides enough relief to keep your pressure points under check. The result is that you won’t get up with any pains in your body.
Hot sleepers: If you are looking for cushioning with support, this mattress’s medium-firm configuration is ideal. This mattress is a suitable option for hot sleepers, thanks to the Cooling Cloud foam layer that is gel-infused.
Additional support: A sleep surface that provides cushioning and offers support it’s a good choice because it comes with a 6-inch thick support layer of HD foam.
May not be best for…
Stomach sleepers: To sleep for an extended period, this is not the right mattress for you. You can rest on it for some time, but you will need more firmness in your sleep surface to get enough support all night long. With his mattress, your hips will sag, resulting in backache.
If you need that enveloping feel: This mattress features gel-infused memory foam in its top layer and provides temperature regulation. But if you are looking for maximum conformance and prefer to sleep on an enveloping surface, this is not the right option.
Who The Purple Mattress Is Best For
Best for…
Budget buyers: The Purple mattress is a better choice if you want to save a few extra bucks. It’s one of the most budget-friendly options that you can go for on the market.
Hot sleepers: Again, the top layer featuring GelFlex Grid can wick moisture away and regulate temperature, allowing you to sleep cool all night. So, it’s a pretty good choice for hot sleepers.
Hypoallergenic properties: Purple mattresses are made of premium quality materials and don’t have any harmful chemicals in them. Similar is the case with the Purple mattress as it has no toxic materials and is Clean Air GOLD certified.
May not be best for…
Heavyweight sleepers: Purple mattresses might not be suitable for anyone weighing over 230 lbs. Heavier sleepers will notice that their hips tend to sag when sleeping on a purple mattress. It might not be that bad because the mattress has some medium-firmness, but this is not the right option to sleep every night.
Not enough edge support: The Purple mattress might come with a medium-firm feel and has some support to offer, but if you are looking for adequate edge support, you need to look elsewhere. Memory foam mattresses are not good when it comes to edge support.
A Comprehensive Comparison of Puffy Vs. Purple Mattress Features
Construction
The Puffy mattress has 5 layers of cloud-like comfort with an overall feel of 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. The top layer is the stain-resistant cover with hypoallergenic materials to keep your mattress clean and fresh.
The second layer features 2-inch Cooling Cloud foam that has gel-infused in it. This layer works well for hot sleepers as it regulates temperature and wicks moisture.
After that, a 2-inch Climate Comfort foam layer relieves pressure and provides you with that envoli[ping feel that you crave without compromising support.
The 4th layer in this mattress features a 6-inch core support layer that comes firm. It is HD foam and helps the mattress to stabilize and increase its longevity.
This base layer covers with gripping fabric allowing your Puffy mattress to hold its place if you decide to put it on an adjustable base or any other flipper surface (also check top-rated mattresses for an adjustable bed). So, no need to frequently reposition your mattress.
The Purple mattress, on the other hand, has a pretty similar construction featuring 5 different foam layers. Right at the top is the SoftFlex knit cover that will allow you to feel comfortable and notice that GelFlex Grid is right underneath it.
After that, there is a 2-inch GelFlex Grid layer of breathable materials, and it will provide you with the necessary pressure relief to keep your spine aligned no matter which position you prefer to sleep in.
Then comes the comfort and support layers. At the top, there is a cushioning comfort layer that is 3.5-inch in thickness, and it pairs well with the 4-inch firmer base layer to provide you with a perfect balance between support and comfort. Both these layers are HD polyurethane foam.
Firmness
Regarding firmness, the Puffy mattress has a medium firm feel with 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. This mattress does a pretty good job of providing the perfect balance between cushioning and support.
With these properties, the Puffy mattress is an ideal choice for combo sleepers and even side and back sleepers (check the top rated mattresses for side sleepers). It will give you the conformance you need to relieve pressure while keeping your spine aligned.
But this mattress is not a good choice if you prefer to sleep strictly on your stomach. Stomach sleepers should go for a firmer mattress for better support and prevention of any sagging, especially around the hip area.
The Purple mattress comes with a firmness level rated medium firm at around 6.5 out of 10. So, it is not a good choice for lightweight stomach sleepers because it is slightly softer than a Puffy mattress.
However, if you are a combo sleeper, this mattress is a good choice. It does provide you with that conforming feel up to some extent as well. But the base layer at the end does a fine job keeping your spine well aligned throughout the night if you prefer to sleep on your side or your back.
This mattress has enough pressure relief to enable you to sleep in most positions. But if you are strictly a stomach sleeper, you should go for another mattress (check 10 amazing mattresses for stomach sleepers).
And if you are a heavyweight sleeper (check 10 great mattresses for overweight people), this mattress won’t provide enough support, making your hips sag right at the center, resulting in backaches. However, this mattress is a good choice for anyone weighing around 130 lbs to 230 lbs.
Motion Isolation and Edge Support
A puffy mattress is a gel-infused memory foam mattress that pretty much tells you about everything how this mattress will perform when it comes to motion isolation and edge support.
Gel-infused memory foam or true memory foam mattresses are pretty good in motion isolation, particularly true memory foam mattresses.
But as Puffy mattresses come with gel-infused memory foam, it will provide you with enough motion isolation that you won’t disturb if your partner tends to move a lot at night (check the best selling mattresses for couple).
And with edge support, Puffy mattresses are not that great. If you are specifically looking for edge support, you should consider buying innerspring or hybrid mattresses because they are the best for edge support (check the top rated hybrid mattresses).
Gel-infused memory foam mattresses and true memory foam mattresses are not significant in this aspect, which is pretty much the case with Puffy mattresses.
Just like any other true memory foam or gel-infused memory foam mattress, the Purple mattress is pretty good regarding motion isolation (also check the top-rated mattresses similar to Purple).
True memory foam mattresses tend to perform better in this aspect. However, gel-infused memory foam mattresses are not far behind. So, the Purple mattress is pretty good regarding motion isolation.
But when we talk about edge support, you won’t find this particular mattress much handy. Just like any other true or gel-infused memory mattress, the Purple mattress doesn’t come with enough edge support.
No matter how firm these mattresses are, you can’t match them with the edge support that innerspring and hybrid mattresses offer (check the best selling innerspring mattresses).
Temperature Regulation
Memory foam mattresses tend to conform pretty well. Many people crave that developing feeling that a sleep surface has to offer. But this feeling can make you feel hot as it retains
And if you are a hot sleeper, these features will turn against you. And that is exactly why mattress manufacturers started using gel-infused memory foam. These mattresses come with a special top layer that has gel crystals in them.
These crystals are highly effective in regulating temperature and directing heat elsewhere in the mattress, keeping you comfortable throughout the night even if you sleep hot.
Puffy has done the same thing with its mattress and has used gel-infused memory foam in its top layer to regulate temperature and wick any moisture so you can comfortably enjoy a goodnight’s rest.
It features Cooling Cloud foam as its top layer that is highly breathable. Even the second layer in the Puffy mattress that provides pressure relief has cooling properties to keep you nice and comfortable during your sleep.
Purple has used gel-infused technology in its top layer to ensure the mattress keeps channeling your body heat, allowing you to rest more comfortably. These gel crystals absorb the heat from your body and come in handy when wicking moisture away.
Purple has gone a step ahead of its competition and has introduced a special 2-inch GelFlex Grid in its mattresses. This grid design conforms well according to your body shape and provides conformance while keeping your body less in contact with the mattress and allowing more airflow.
This design has proven revolutionary, allowing Purple mattresses to be highly breathable despite being pretty conforming. The rest of the job is done by the gel infusion in the top layer, resulting in a comfortable night’s sleep without a sweat.
Position and Body Type
The Puffy mattress is gel-infused memory foam; this mattress is a good option for side and back sleepers. We would say that is a good choice, even for combo sleepers. It has enough cushioning and support, making it work for any sleeping position.
However, if you are strictly a stomach sleeper, we suggest you go for another mattress because the Puffy mattress is not firm enough to keep your spine aligned as you sleep on your stomach night in and night out.
Apart from that, Puffy is a good choice for most sleepers weighing up to 230 lbs. Thanks to its medium-firm feel, it works well for most body types.
But if you are a heavyweight sleeper weighing over 230 lbs, you will have to deal with your hips sagging on this sleeping surface, resulting in lower back pains (check 10 amazing mattresses for back pain).
Just like Puffy, the Purple mattress also comes with a medium-firm feel, so it is a good choice for anyone who prefers to sleep on the side or back. It works just fine for combo sleepers.
But if you prefer to sleep on your back more often, this mattress is not the right choice because it doesn’t provide your body enough firmness. Consequently, your hips will sag as you sleep on this mattress daily, and it will start causing backaches.
It is not a good option for people weighing over 230 lbs because Purple tends to sag from the center. It is ideal for people under 230 lbs as it will provide enough cushioning and support, and you won’t have to deal with any sagging.
Price Range
The Purple mattress is more affordable than the Puffy mattress. So, if you’re looking for a budget pick, go for the Purple mattress. Here’s a comprehensive price comparison table with each size (also check 10 top-quality mattresses under 2,000 dollars).
| Puffy Mattress | Purple Mattress | |
| Twin | $1449 | $799 |
| Twin XL | $1499 | $999 |
| Full | $1649 | $1199 |
| Queen | $1799 | $1399 |
| King | $1999 | $1799 |
| Cal King | $1999 | $1799 |
| Split King | – | $1998 |
Puffy vs Purple – Reviews from Actual Buyers
Maria S. from Los Angeles, CA
“I’ve had my Puffy mattress for about 6 months now and I’m really happy with it. I’m primarily a side sleeper and this mattress provides the perfect amount of pressure relief on my hips and shoulders. It’s not too soft where I sink in completely, but also not too firm where I feel unsupported. The cooling cloud foam has really helped reduce the night sweats I used to get with my old memory foam mattress too. Highly recommend for side sleepers!”
James T. from Houston, TX
“My wife and I went with the Purple mattress after debating between it and the Puffy mattress for a while. We’re both combination sleepers and wanted something that would accommodate both back and stomach sleeping. For us, the Purple provides a good medium feel that isn’t too plush or too firm. My wife says it relieves pressure points well for her side sleeping and I haven’t had any back pain like on some softer mattresses when sleeping on my stomach. Overall we’re very satisfied with the Purple after 1 year.”
Samantha R. from Denver, CO
“I recently purchased a Puffy mattress and unfortunately have to return it. As a strict stomach sleeper, I found it much too soft and unsupportive. My hips sank in quite a bit, putting strain on my lower back which I noticed immediately upon waking. I think the Puffy would accommodate side sleepers really well, but for stomach sleepers like myself it just doesn’t offer enough support. I’ll be looking for a firmer mattress option instead that will keep my spine aligned.”
Verdict
Both Puffy and Purple mattresses are almost identical in what they have to offer to different types of sleepers based on their sleeping references and their body types, they make sure to offer comfortable mattresses to all sleepers.
But if you are looking for value shopping, you should consider going for Puffy as it comes with a lifetime warranty as opposed to the 10-year warranty that Purple has to offer. And if you are a budget shopper, consider going for Purple because their mattresses cost less than Puffy.