by Puffy and Saatva are highly recognizable brands in the mattress industry. Puffy is well known for using innovative technologies in its mattress manufacturing. Saatva is one of the best brands globally as it has been manufacturing quality mattresses for residential and commercial clients (also check the top rated mattresses).
In this guide, we will compare Puffy Mattress vs. Saatva Classic Mattress and see which one is better for whom.
Comparison Table – Puffy Vs. Saatva
| Puffy Mattress | Saatva Classic Mattress | |
| Best for | · Hot Sleepers
· Side and back sleepers |
· Combination sleepers
· People with lower back problems |
| Trial Period | 101 nights | 365 nights |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime |
| Price range | $1449 – $1999 | $812 – $2146 |
The Key Differences Between Puffy Vs. Saatva
Who The Puffy Mattress Is Best For:
Best for…
Back and side sleepers: A puffy mattress is an excellent option for those who prefer to sleep on their side or back (check the top rated mattresses for side sleepers). It conforms well and keeps your spine aligned regardless of your sleep position.
Pressure relief: This mattress works incredibly if you want to relieve pressure from your joints. It contours well thanks to its comfort layer with gel-infused memory foam.
Motion isolation: Gel-infused memory foams are much better regarding motion isolation. This mattress will work fine if you share your bed with a partner who moves around during sleep (check the best selling mattresses for couple).
Conformance: If you want more conformance in your mattress, you should consider going for Puffy Mattress, as it features gel-infused memory foam in its comfort layer and contours pretty well.
May not be best for…
Strict stomach sleepers: Being infused with gel, the comfort layer of this mattress contours pretty well (also check 9 amazing mattress toppers for stomach sleepers). It is not ideal for people who prefer to sleep on their stomachs, or their hips will sag due to the plushness of the sleep surface.
Plus-sized sleepers: People over 230 pounds won’t find the Puffy mattress an ideal choice because it is too soft to provide better support to heavier people (also check 10 great mattresses for overweight people). This is because the sleep surface will sag due to the weight, and it will cause your spine to misalign and cause back pain.
Who The Saatva Classic Mattress Is Best For:
Best for…
Combination sleepers: Saatva Classic Mattress is an innerspring mattress that works well for combination sleepers. There is enough support and conformance for you no matter what sleep position you prefer.
Better airflow: Innerspring mattresses are suitable for airflow, thanks to their coil system. And same is the case with the Saatva Classic mattress.
Back pain: Thanks to its design and construction, the Saatva Classic Mattress is a good choice if you want additional support to deal with your back pain (also check 10 amazing mattresses for back pain).
Choosing your comfort level: Saatva allows you to choose your preferred firmness combination for your Saatva Classic Mattress.
May not be best for…
Plus-sized people: This mattress is not an ideal choice for plus-size people, even though different firmness configurations are available. It will affect the overall durability of the mattress.
Motion isolation: Innerspring mattresses are not that great in motion isolation (also check the top rated mattresses for motion isolation), especially if you compare them with memory foam or gel-infused memory foam mattresses, and that’s the case with Saatva Classic Mattress.
Top Features Compared – Puffy Vs. Saatva
Construction
Puffy mattress features a stain-resistant cloud cover right at the top of the mattress and is made of hypoallergenic materials to prevent skin or respiratory allergies.
Next comes the gel-infused memory foam comfort layer called the Cooling Cloud Foam layer, and it is there to keep your sleep experience as breezy as possible.
After that is the Climate Comfort foam layer, which features pressure-relieving properties and provides a perfect balance between cushioning and support.
At the bottom is the core support layer made of HD foam, which provides the mattress stability. This base layer is covered with a gripping layer that prevents the mattress from slipping.
Saatva Classic mattress comes with multiple layers. Right at the top is the breathable and plush sleep surface, which features a Euro pillow top paired with Lumbar Zone quilting. The cover of this layer is made of organic and hypoallergenic materials.
Next comes the enhanced back support with the Lumbar Zone Active Spinal Wire layer to ensure better spinal alignment and support for your lower back.
The third layer has responsive coils that cradle your body with 884 pocketed coils. This layer is paired with HD foam rials to ensure better edge support and keep your mattress in shape for a long time.
And right at the end is the base layer featuring a dual-coil system that enhances the ability of the mattress to keep the sleep surface cool and effectively channel your body heat.
Firmness
This mattress comes with a medium-firm feel, rated 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale. It means this mattress is a pretty good option for combination sleepers.
It is enough to provide you with contouring if you prefer to sleep on your side or your back, and it will work out pretty well for you if you tend to sleep on your stomach for some time.
This firmness level is not ideal for those who strictly prefer to sleep on their stomachs. It is because you will need a much firmer mattress, your hips will sag, and your spine will go out of alignment. Consequently, you will have to deal with lower back pains when you get up in the morning.
One of the best features of the Saatva Classic mattress is that you will have the option of choosing the comfort level that you want to derive from your mattress. This mattress comes with three different firmness levels. You can choose from Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm configurations (also check 10 top-quality plush mattresses).
Whether you prefer to sleep on your side, your back, your stomach, or you are a combo sleeper. This mattress will prove to be a suitable choice.
The plush soft mattress is a good choice for petite sleepers or if you have to deal with joint pain. The luxury firm option is better for most side and back sleepers (also check 10 great pillows for back sleepers).
And the firm option is suitable for plus-sized sleepers and those who prefer to sleep on their stomachs. This mattress is suitable for most sleepers, and you can go for the right type of firmness according to your sleep preferences.
Motion Isolation and Edge Support
The Puffy mattress is a pretty good option if you are looking for motion isolation. These features will help you if you share your bed with someone more likely to move around during sleep.
Gel-infused memory foam mattresses do well as they restrict motion transfer. They might not be as good as true memory foam mattresses. They are a better choice than innerspring, latex, and hybrid mattresses.
With most memory foam mattresses infused with gel, this mattress is not that great when discussing edge support. So, the mattress will lose shape and take time to return to its original shape.
This mattress tends to deteriorate faster in the long run than latex, hybrid, and innerspring mattresses.
Saatva Classic mattress is an innerspring mattress with a coil system. Therefore, this mattress might not be a very good choice if you are looking to buy a new mattress specifically for motion isolation.
Therefore, if you are buying a mattress to deter motion from being caused by the twisting and turning of your partner, then you need to look elsewhere.
You can choose a different level of firmness to be in more control of this situation. Still, this mattress won’t be as effective as true memory foam or a gel-infused memory mattress.
Nevertheless, it performs pretty well as far as edge support is concerned. This mattress has a coil system, and innerspring mattresses tend to work pretty well to keep the mattress in shape with a higher recovery rate.
Temperature Regulation
Puffy mattress is a decent choice if you want temperature regulation. This mattress comes with gel infusion in its comfort layer and is generally good at channeling your body heat.
There is not much in this mattress apart from that. So, if you are a hot sleeper, you might have to consider this aspect of the Puffy Mattress (check the top choice cooling mattresses for hot sleepers).
Gel-infused memory foam mattresses are not great at regulating temperature if you compare them with hybrids, latex, and innerspring mattresses.
Thanks to the gel crystals in the comfort layer, it will undoubtedly perform better than a conventional memory foam mattress.
Saatva Classic mattress does a fine job when it comes to temperature regulation. This mattress comes with coil systems in two different layers. There is a layer that features pocketed coils and coiling in the base layer.
Therefore, the mattress does well when effectively channeling your body heat. Innerspring mattresses perform better than any other mattress type when temperature regulation matters the most.
So, if you are a hot sleeper, this mattress will work for you as it won’t provide you with that sinking feeling you must deal with when you sleep on a memory foam mattress. There is no better option you can look for in this regard.
Position and Body Type
Puffy Mattresses will work just fine for side and back sleepers and those who are combination sleepers with the gel technology it has in its comfort layer. The mattress functions well and contours according to your body shape.
It means whether you sleep on your side or your back, the top layer of the mattress will conform, and it will provide you with the necessary cushioning to keep your spine properly aligned and relieve your joints in the process.
Furthermore, the Puffy mattress is suitable for most body types too. It works well for people who weigh between 130 and 230 pounds. However, it might not be the right option for plus-sized or petite sleepers.
Saatva Classic mattress is an innerspring mattress that allows you to choose your comfort level and is a top choice for almost all sleepers (also check the most comfortable mattresses).
Innerspring mattresses, on their own, are suitable for back and stomach sleepers (check 10 amazing mattresses for stomach sleepers) in most cases because they don’t provide much cushioning if you compare them with memory foam or gel-infused memory foam mattresses.
Saatva resolves that issue by allowing you to choose from three different firmness configurations. Whether you prefer sleeping on your back, stomach, or side, this mattress will be a fine choice.
It means you can choose the right firmness option according to your body type. Whether you are plus-sized, petite, or weigh between 130 to 230 lbs, this mattress can work wonders for you by providing you with a perfect balance between cushioning and support.
Price Range
If you look at the prices of different sizes available in both these mattresses, you will see a slight difference, with Saatav being on the lower end of the price spectrum.
The difference is much bigger if you go for smaller-sized mattresses. Both come with a lifetime warranty, but Saatva does offer 365-night sleep trials as opposed to the 101-night sleep trial of Puffy.
| Puffy Mattress | Saatva Classic Mattress | |
| Twin | $1449 | $812 |
| Twin XL | $1499 | $998 |
| Full | $1649 | $1470 |
| Queen | $1799 | $1570 |
| King | $1999 | $1970 |
| Cal King | $1999 | $1970 |
| Split King | – | $2146 |
| Split Cal King | – | $2146 |
Which mattress sleeps cooler – Puffy or Saatva?
The Puffy tends to sleep a bit cooler than the Saatva. The Puffy has a heat-responsive foam layer designed to draw heat away from the body. The Saatva relies more on airflow through its coil layer, but the foam comfort layers don’t dissipate heat quite as well. Both are decent options for those who tend to sleep hot, but the Puffy has a slight edge.
What kind of foundations can I use with Puffy and Saatva?
You can use either mattress on adjustable bases, slatted platforms, box springs, and solid or bunkie board foundations. It’s best to use solid platforms with the Saatva to support the weight of the coils. Always check the manufacturer’s recommendations. But both are quite flexible and work on most standard bases and bed frames.
Verdict
If you look at all the pros and cons of both these mattresses, you will see that Saatva has a clear advantage over Puffy as it provides you with an option to customize your mattress firmness configuration according to your preferences. The prices are relatively lower (check 10 amazing mattresses under 2000 dollars).
In addition to the lifetime warranty that Puffy offers, Saatva has a 365-night sleep trial as opposed to Puffy’s 101-night sleep trial. It has two more sizes available: Split King and Split Cal King (also check 10 good split king mattresses).