by With a wide range of online mattresses available, you might be confused about which one to choose (also check the top rated mattresses). The most popular companies in mattress manufacturing include Saatva, Tuft, and Needle.
These companies make sure to create mattresses that are highly durable and reliable. Tuft and Needle create the mattress within a box with an adaptable foam, which blends well to provide the user with a durable, confirming mattress. On the other hand, Saatva offers the innerspring luxurious hybrid models, which are available at competitive prices (check the top rated luxury mattresses). This mattress is not available in a box but is delivered with a white glove.
Let’s find out the breakdown of both mattresses, including the size, price, mattress motion isolation technology, firmness, and so on.
Comparison Table – Saatva vs. Tuft & Needle
| Saatva Classic | Tuft and Needle Original | |
| Best for | Regulates temperature
Pressure-relieving effect |
Pressure-reliving effect
Resists any heat retention Stomach and back sleepers |
| Trial Period | 365-night trial | 100-night trial |
| Warranty | Lifetime warranty | 10 years warranty |
| Price range | $912 – $2396 | $645 – $1095 |
The Key Differences Between Saatva vs. Tuft & Needle
Who The Saatva Classic Mattress is Best For?
Best for…
Different sleeping positions: This mattress is great for people with varying sleeping positions.
Couples: It is good to buy if you purchase it for a couple. It features incredible edge support with motion isolation technology.
Medium firmness level: If you seek a medium firmness level for your mattress, you should opt for the innerspring mattress featuring a pillow top.
Pressure-relieving effect: The pressure-relieving effect of this mattress is very nice, which means if you are suffering from muscle pain and joint pain, you should have this mattress.
May not be best for…
Heavyweight sleepers: This mattress is not a great choice for heavy people who weigh more than 230 pounds as it lacks any extra support, especially for stomach sleepers (also check 10 amazing mattresses for stomach sleepers).
Pressure relieving effect: Using the Saatva firm version is better, allowing you to indulge in the better pressure relieving effect (also check the best selling mattress toppers for pressure points).
Who The Tuft & Needle Mattress is Best For?
Best for…
Pressure-relieving effect: The Tuft & Needle mattress comes in adaptive foam, which is engineered in such a way that it offers a pressure-relieving effect to the entire body.
Open cell structure: It features an open cell structure that offers a flexible sleeping surface to the body when sitting well throughout sleep.
Stomach and back sleepers: The Tuft & Needle mattress is brilliant for the stomach and back sleepers. They use the firm base layer as a supportive structure, preventing any sinking or sagging effect.
Cool sleepers: It is phenomenal for cool sleepers because it features open-cell cooling foam technology, which conducts heat through graphite and comes with a gel-infused structure that wicks away all the heat with moisture-wicking technology.
Versatile mattress: If you have been seeking a versatile mattress that fits well with all the foundations and frames ranging from traditional frames, box springs, slatted frames, adjustable frames, and bunky boards, this one is an ultimate choice for such shoppers.
May not be best for…
Heavyweight individuals: This mattress is exemplary for the average-weight stomach, side, and back sleepers, so if you are obese and weigh more than 230 pounds, you’ll experience discomfort while sleeping on this mattress.
Side sleepers: The side sleepers won’t feel comfortable on this mattress, similar to the stomach and back sleepers, because the base of this mattress is thick, making it uncomfortable for the side sleepers to sleep.
Top Features Compared – Saatva vs. Tuft & Needle
Construction
The Saatva mattresses are made with eco-friendly materials and come in a durable design featuring the coil support system. It is one of the popular mattresses by the brand, which is designed to provide spinal alignment with reduced joint and back pain.
The Saatva Classic mattress comes with special features. It has a luxurious pillow featuring organic cotton, which offers a cushioning effect. It comes with antimicrobial fabric support, which allows you to stay fresh throughout the night. Next comes the individually wrapped gauge coils in 14.5, designed for controlling the body.
The next layer includes a durable, strong base with a 13-gauge steel support coil system that prevents any sagging effects. The dual coil system provides a responsive support system which leads to enough airflow within the mattress, allowing you to stay cool throughout the night.
The center part of the traditional mattress comes with the back support, which offers a pressure-relieving effect. The lumbar zone technology in the mattress helps in relieving the tension.
The tuft & needle mattress makes use of the proprietary foam within the mattress. The body shape controls the adaptive foam in this mattress and the pressure relieving effect. This Tuft & needle mattress returns to its original shape as soon as pressure is released. It is easier to get in and out of the mattress. The foam of these mattresses is made using the open cell structure, which allows enough airflow with better temperature regulating properties.
Moreover, this mattress comes with a few ceramic and graphite gel beads, which prevent heat retention within the mattress by wicking away all the moisture. The Tuft & Needle original mattress comes with 10 inches of thickness in a mattress featuring dual layers. In addition, the polyester blend micro polyamide cover is breathable and soft. The initial layer of this mattress comprises 3 inches of adaptive foam, making it a medium firm choice for users. This first layer molds well with the body shape offering a proper contouring effect.
It regulates your temperature better during your sleep. Lastly, the support core for the original mattress is made using the 7-inch polyform with an open cell supportive foam, providing consistent sleep throughout the night.
Firmness
The Saatva Classic mattress is one of the luxurious innerspring hybrid mattresses (check the best selling hybrid mattresses). It is one of the high-end mattresses which comes with premium quality materials.
The classic mattress comes in three different firmness options, which include plush soft, firm, as well as luxury firm. The plush mattress is comfortable for lightweight side sleepers who like sleeping over the soft mattress (also check 10 mattresses with great comfort). It comes with a firmness level of around 3 out of 10.
The luxury firm of the Saatva Classic mattress is ideal for people suffering from back pain and couples with different preferences (check 10 great mattresses for back pain). It is a medium-sized mattress with a rating of 5/7.5 out of 10.
The mattress comes in two other firmness options: medium, which is rated 5 out of 10, and medium firm, which is greater than 6 out of 10. This mattress’s medium and medium firm level makes it a superb choice, especially for stomach and back sleepers who need ultimate support with proper spine alignment during sleep.
Motion Isolation and Edge Support
Motion isolation is about reducing the transfer of motion from one side of the bed to another, while edge support is about offering extensive surface area for sleepers. These two properties are fundamental to consider when buying a mattress for couples (also check the top-quality mattresses for motion isolation).
The motion isolation technology of the Saatva Classic is amazing because it isolates the motion transfer with this mattress, which means you won’t be disturbed during sleep. As a result, this mattress is an excellent choice for couples.
The Tuft and Needle foam mattresses are rated for motion isolation technology that easily exerts pressure and slowly returns to their original shape as soon as the pressure is removed. Sleepers who intend to share a mattress should prioritize motion isolation technology when purchasing a mattress.
The Saatva classic mattress is sturdy and allows the sleepers to sit over the edge without any sinking or sagging effect. You will not experience any unpleasant sinking sensation while sitting on this mattress. The edge support with the Saatva Classic mattress is incredible.
The tuft and needle mattress offers less edge support, which is rated around 2 out of 5, making it a good choice for support if you are buying it as a couple. Saatva classic, on the other hand, is rated 4 out of 5 in terms of edge support, so if you are buying it for a couple, it is better to opt for Saatva classic.
Temperature
With the Saatva Classic mattress, there is no more heat retention with the mattress as you won’t feel any discomfort as the temperature of your body will remain neutral all night long without making you feel too cold or hot during sleep.
In comparison, the Tuft & Needle features open cell cooling technology with the prosperity blended foam that works well in terms of conducting heat. It features a cooling gel infused with graphite and ceramic beads blended well with the adaptive foam, which removes all the heat and moisture, helping you indulge in a night of restful deep sleep.
Position and Body Type
The firmness, as well as the thickness option of the Satva Classic mattress, make it a perfect choice for all sleepers. The medium feel of these mattresses is ideal for people who are lighter in weight, especially the side sleepers. It might work well for heavy people in the medium firm level (also check 10 amazing mattresses for overweight people) and the firm setting, especially for stomach and back sleepers.
The Saatva Classic mattress is perfect for those who sleep hot throughout the night with improved circulation because the coil keeps you comfortable.
In contrast, the Tuft & Needle mattress has a medium-firm feel and is an optimal choice for people who weigh less than 130 lbs. Lighter individuals will find the mattress supportive and comfortable. Heavy individuals will feel discomfort while sleeping on this mattress. The Tuft & Needle mattress is a superb choice for couples who want motion isolation technology in their mattresses.
Price Range
Saatva Classic is a brand that offers luxurious mattresses at affordable prices (check the best selling mattresses under 2,000 dollars). The tuft & needle mattress, on the other hand, provides a proprietary blend of foam and comfort system, which is affordable compared to the Saatva Classic mattress.
If you are seeking the Tuft and Needle mattress with all-foam, check out the price range for different sizes; however, if you are seeking Saatva Classic mattress in high-end products, choose this brand as it comes at an affordable price featuring an innerspring mattress.
| Saatva classic | Tuft & Needle Original | |
| Twin | $912 | $633 |
| Twin XL | $1198 | $675 |
| Full | $1670 | $760 |
| Queen | $1770 | $845 |
| King | $2170 | $1185 |
| Cal King | $2170 | $1185 |
| Split king | $2396 | – |
| Split Cal king | $2396 | – |
How do the materials used in Saatva and Tuft & Needle mattresses impact environmental sustainability?
Both Saatva and Tuft & Needle emphasize the use of quality materials in their mattresses. Saatva, for instance, uses eco-friendly materials, which suggests a commitment to environmental sustainability. Tuft & Needle’s proprietary foam and open-cell structure also hint at innovative material use. Potential buyers often look for eco-friendly options, so understanding the environmental impact of these mattresses can be a deciding factor.
How do Saatva and Tuft & Needle handle returns during their trial periods?
While both brands offer trial periods (365-night for Saatva and 100-night for Tuft & Needle), the specifics of their return policies during these periods can be crucial for customers. Details like return shipping fees, restocking fees, or potential donations of returned mattresses can influence a buyer’s decision.
Verdict
The Tuft & Needle original mattress comes in all firmness levels. At the same time, the Saatva Classic is a hybrid mattress with the top layer featuring the memory foam layer with pocketed coils and, lastly, the innerspring base. Unfortunately, the Tuft & Needle mattress is available only in medium firm choice.
In contrast, the Saatva mattress allows you to choose different firmness levels ranging from plush soft to luxury firm. The mattresses by the Saatva brand offer a price range that is comparatively expensive compared to the Tuft & Needle mattresses. Saatva mattresses are one of the most luxurious than Tuft & Needle mattresses.
Tuft & Needle is a budget-friendly company (check 10 great mattresses under 1000 dollars). If you have been seeking a responsive mattress that controls well with the body, featuring the open cell construction, then a tuft and needle mattress is perfect. However, if you are seeking the best of all the mattresses, with improved spinal alignment and fantastic breathing mattress, with high durability and eco-friendly material, the Saatva mattress is a considerable choice.