by Crib mattresses are designed especially with children’s comfort in mind. The best non-toxic cot mattresses use materials that are child friendly. Unsuitable beds can harm a baby’s health and should be avoided.
New parents may be overwhelmed by the options and are unaware of the distinctions. To help you decide, we have compared Newton and Naturepedic crib mattresses.
They are both well-known brands (check 10 amazing mattresses). Both brands have loyal customers, which confuses new buyers about which to buy.
There are many differences between these two brands; the table below will help you understand them quickly. An analysis of your baby’s well-being and your lifestyle will reveal the best fit.
Comparison Table – Naturepedic Vs. Newton
| Naturepedic | Newton Baby | |
|
Best For |
Wet or spit-up-prone kids.
Parents who buy eco-friendly kid products. |
Buyers of a washable baby crib mattress.
Families who live in hot climates. Babies who are easily startled by noisy mattresses. |
| Trial Period | 90-night sleep | 100-night sleep |
| Warranty | 20 years | Limited lifetime warranty |
| Price Range | $399 – $449 | $250 – $350 |
The Key Differences Between Naturepedic Vs. Newton
Who Is The Naturepedic Crib Mattress Best For
Best for…
Parents seeking hypoallergenic materials: Using natural cotton construction materials for this safety-certified organic crib mattress makes it an excellent choice. As a result, it is entirely hypoallergenic, with no dangerous chemicals or flame retardants.
Someone who prefers a water-resistant surface: Because the mattress is waterproof, spills and accidents can be easily cleaned up without causing damage to the bed.
Every sleeping position: These organic mattresses allow your child to sleep in any situation, regardless of body weight. Its sturdy innerspring core is appropriate for infants and young children (also check the best mattresses for kids).
May not best for:
People who want a breathable mattress: Because of its waterproofing and design, the Naturepedic isn’t as breathable, but the quilted cover provides airflow for your baby.
People who prefer a softer mattress: Because it is a firm mattress, this might not attract some parents who choose a more peaceful option for their infants.
Who Is The Newton Original Crib Mattress Best For
Best for…
For those looking for breathable materials: this mattress includes Newton’s patented “Breathe-Thru” technology that helps your baby sleep peacefully.
Who likes easy cleaning: It is ideal for first-time parents since it is lightweight and quickly cleanable at home, making it simple and convenient to maintain.
Health-conscious parents: It contains no harmful products, such as allergy-causing chemicals and materials, and it adheres to national safety standards and guidelines.
May not be best for…
People looking for a low-cost mattress: It can be limited in size and expensive, especially if you want a waterproof mattress.
Someone sensitive to odors: The new mattress may have an overpowering smell when first opened. This mattress emits off-gassing, making it unsuitable for people exposed to odors.
Top Features compared – Naturepedic Vs. Newton
Construction:
The Naturepedic Classic Organic Mattress is a water-resistant mattress consisting of natural cotton, innerspring, and a waterproof cover. Certified organic cotton and a 150-coil steel innerspring make it a good choice for anyone with allergies or asthma.
The mattress cover has a waterproof coating made of non-GMO sugarcane. As a result, you can easily clean spillages or diaper leaks. However, comparing Naturepedic vs. Newton baby crib mattresses, the Newton mattress isn’t waterproof.
Natural materials and no polyfoam or flame retardants make the Naturepedic crib mattress chemical-free. It also has GOTS and Greenguard certifications, proving that it is safe for your child and the environment.
Newton Crib Mattresses addresses multiple features with its innovative 100 percent breathable construction. The Original is 5.5 inches deep and features a dual-layer cover for added comfort.
The Newton Crib Mattress comprises a polymer core structure supported by a zippered removable cover. It consists of the patented Wovenaire material and a spacer cover.
This material resembles dry ramen noodles. The space between the “noodles” is full of air, so this cot mattress is 90% air! You can put your face against the mattress and still breathe. It makes the bed firm, breathable, and lightweight, great for changing sheets or cleaning.
Wovenaire’s “breathe through” layout is challenging to beat, particularly for infants under one as they get bigger and switch onto their tummies at night. Air-circulation reduces SID risk, regulates mattress temperature, and is ideal for parents with respiratory problems or other breathing concerns.
The pungent smell of the Newton mattress upon opening may distress some people. However, the materials used to make the naturepedic traditional crib mattress prevent it from smelling bad. So, in terms of construction material, Naturepedic is a better option than Newton.
Firmness:
If you push it down in the center, the crib mattress must be firm enough to spring back to its initial form quickly. A firm crib mattress supports the spinal column and prevents your baby from getting stuck in a soft one.
The No CompromiseTM in naturepedic crib mattress provides superior support for your infant or toddler. The bed has 2-Stage dual firmness, with one side designed for babies and the other for toddlers. The firm (8) side is designed for growing babies who require additional support while sleeping safely and comfortably. Once your child is a toddler, you can flip the mattress to make it softer and more comfortable (also check 10 top-rated mattresses with great comfort).
The durable 150 coil innerspring contributes to this firm flat surface, giving your child the ideal support. It adheres to pediatrician and Consumer Product Safety Commission recommendations for firmness.
The Newton Crib Mattress is a firm mattress suitable for infants and toddlers. The mattress has a firmness rating of 7/10, indicating that it is a firm bed. As a result, rather than sinking into the bed, babies and children lie on top of it.
Most Newton breathable crib mattresses are made with the brand’s specialized Wovenaire® Core. This material is distinct in that it comprises independently spun plastic threads. When these fibers are pushed together, they make a stable polymer block that is both supportive and bouncy and returns to its original firmness quickly. The firmness of this mattress positions the sleeper on the structure’s top.
Size And Weight:
If it comes to the topic of how much a crib mattress weighs, there are two aspects to think about.
- High build quality
- Simple to lift and clean
One of the implicit chores of parenthood is changing a crib sheet. It’s a difficult task because, unlike adult mattresses, you will have to lift the complete mattress out of bed. A lighter-weight mattress can make it easier, and you’ll be more prone to alter the sheets frequently.
The weight of crib mattresses varies greatly. Much of the distinction is due to the filling used. Spring mattresses are more durable, but Newton and Naturepedic make lightweight mattresses with innovative technology.
Naturepedic’s crib mattress weighs 10-12 pounds, making it easy to change BB’s sheets. It will fit most basic cribs and nursery furniture with 27 1/4″ X 51 5/8″ X 6″. Compared to traditional coil mattresses, the innerspring support core is firm yet incredibly lightweight; it weighs 11 lbs.
The original Newton weighs 11 pounds and measures 52 inches in length, 28 inches in width, and 5.5 inches thick. Newton Baby’s specialized support core material is made up of 90percent air and 10 percent food-grade polymer. As a result, the Newton Crib Mattress is remarkably lighter and easier to lift due to its airy construction.
Baby mattresses must be cleaned more thoroughly than adult mattresses. A lightweight bed makes the parent’s life much easier in this situation. In addition, soft mattresses are simple to lift for cleaning and maintenance. Heavy mattresses can strain your back (check 10 great mattresses for back pain).
These models are lightweight, making them simple to use and lift. In addition, these mattresses make it easier for parents to remove the mattress pad from the crib when needed.
Temperature:
The breathability and contouring of a mattress are affected by its materials and construction and have the most significant influence on temperature control. Relatively cool air enters and relieves heat accumulation if a bed has open areas where air can permeate.
The quantity of heat retained by a mattress is a critical factor. Unfortunately, the infant and toddler sides of the Naturepedic bed do not contain much heat.
The toddler side takes 44 secs to lower the temperature from 130 degrees Fahrenheit to 98 degrees, while the infant side takes 30 seconds. The average is between 20 and 25 seconds. It means there’s more insulation inside.
It can be beneficial when it comes to the cooler months. Instead of wearing a blanket, which can cause suffocation in infants, your baby will stay warm naturally. Airflow beneath the baby enables heat to escape efficiently, assisting in temperature regulation for much less sweaty backs. In addition, the innerspring and washable cover will keep your child calm at night.
Newton Baby is by far the more breathable of the two. The Newton Crib Mattress outperforms most foam mattresses in terms of thermal control. Parents should not be concerned about their baby, kid’s sweat, or overheating on this mattress.
Although it is classified as a foam model, the Newton Crib Mattress is made of Wovenaire, which is 90percent air and 10 percent food-grade polymer. The mattress is highly ventilated due to the presence of air pockets throughout.
The circulation of cool air through these pockets keeps excess heat from being trapped inside the mattress while the baby sleeps. In addition, the mattress’ breathability helps keep babies cool while sleeping, so it’s a good choice for hot climates (check the top rated cooling mattresses for hot sleepers).
Washability:
Compared to an adult mattress, a crib mattress has much more. Baby poop, urine, vomit, and more stains than our obsessive minds can fathom. Therefore, it is critical to keep the mattress clean to ensure the baby’s health and safety.
The naturepedic crib mattress has seamless water-resistant edges and a waterproof surface, which aids in bacterial buildup prevention. In addition, the waterproof texture meets food contact standards, and water-resistant seams prevent moisture penetration.
Because of its waterproof materials, you will not need to wash this mattress. This impervious surface simplifies life for many parents.
In this regard, Newton has the upper hand. The Original Crib Mattress’s design makes it simple to clean and convenient for parents. For parents concerned about stains and dirt, this is the best option for a nice and clean mattress after each wash. It is the only cot mattress that can be cleaned from top to bottom. In addition, because there is no foam, glue, latex, or springs, your baby will sleep in a cleaner, hypoallergenic environment.
Their unique construction technology enables you to rinse the full mattress without worry. In addition, the central layer can be spot-cleaned and rinsed in the shower in case of a bigger mess or as part of routine cleaning.
However, the polymer dries quickly in a well-ventilated area, allowing parents to put their baby back to bed after an accident. Hence, you can regularly clean up accidents and drool stains to keep the dust mites away from your baby.
Sleeping Position:
A baby’s health is directly related to the position in which he sleeps. The naturepedic traditional mattress is appropriate for your baby’s sleeping position. Sleeping on the back can improve your baby’s spinal comfort and help their stability and posture.
However, some infants will change positions in the middle of the night and roll over onto their stomachs. This mattress’ firmness and durable innerspring core will support and stabilize your baby’s body so he can sleep in any position (check 10 amazing mattresses for stomach sleepers).
The Newton original Crib Mattress is an excellent choice for nearly all newborns, toddlers, and young children. This model provides exceptional comfort and support for young sleepers weighing less than 130 pounds, regardless of their preferred sleep position (also check the best selling mattresses for side sleepers).
When lying on the Newton Crib Mattress, toddlers who favor sleeping on their sides should experience good support that encourages proper spinal alignment. Their weight must be evenly distributed across the surface, reducing pressure buildup.
To minimize the risk of SIDS, parents are generally advised to have their newborns sleep on their backs. Parents of Back sleepers will appreciate the Newton Crib Mattress. Its level of firmness offers the necessary support while making the bed pleasant for young sleepers.
It is generally advised by medical professionals not to put infants to sleep on their stomachs because doing so can increase the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Toddlers who do this, on the other hand, should receive the assistance they require to stay aligned throughout the night.
Verdict:
As a parent, you’ll probably be happy with either option. However, it is vital to keep in mind that the designs of both mattresses differ, and the details elevate one a little above the other. We recommend Newton Crib Mattress for its price, convenience, and durability.
Naturepedic provides a firm, comfortable, and structured foundation for infants and toddlers. But unfortunately, its sturdiness and design are what justify its hefty price tag, and for some, they may be unnecessary extras.
As a result, Naturepedic mattresses have to be our winner because they combine the convenience of use with safety and comfort for your infant.