Tuft & Needle vs Tempurpedic – Comparing the Top Mattress Brands

If you are looking for the perfect mattress for yourself, and your search has you confused between the Tuft and Needle and the Tempurpedic – we understand. We are here to help you go through what makes these similar, different, and worth the purchase. 

So, go through this review and choose the right mattress for you! 

Comparative Table to Choose Between Tuft & Needle and Tempurpedic 

	Tuft and Needle	Tempurpedic
Best for	Side sleepers	Back sleepers and side sleepers
Trial Period	100-night’s sleep trial	90-night sleep trial
Warranty	10-year warranty	10 years
Price range	$ 745 – $1395	$ 1899 – $ 3798

 The Key Differences Between Tuft & Needle and Tempurpedic  

Who The Tuft and Needle Is Best For:

Best for… 

Value-based shoppers: The Tuft and Needle is a good option for customers looking for affordable options (check 10 amazing mattresses under 1000 dollars). They are economically priced, and the website offers a couple of good deals you can opt for. Their queen-sized mattress is very reasonably priced. 

Medium Weighted combination sleepers: This might be a good option if you are light or medium-weight (check the top rated mattresses for light person). You can easily change positions without feeling stuck and get amazing back support. 

Those who like the foam feel: This is a good option if you are a fan of that slow sinking feeling. 

May not be best for…

Stomach Sleepers: This one is specifically not for stomach sleepers. You will find that your hips bow in, and your body gets out of alignment.

Heavy Weighted Sleepers: If you weigh 250 pounds or more, you will have difficulty sleeping on this mattress (check 10 amazing mattresses for overweight people). It will feel as in you have completely sunk into the mattress, making you feel stuck in one place and difficult to move around your bed. 

Who The Tempurpedic Is Best For:

Best for…

Combination Sleepers: If you are a combination sleeper, the Tempurpedic offers the best support on your back and amazing pressure relief on your shoulders when you sleep on your sides (also check the best selling mattress toppers for pressure points). 

Those who love to sink in: This mattress generally has a classic slow-moving memory foam feel. So, if you are into that, this is your ideal pick. 

May not be best for…

Stomach sleepers: This is no surprise; stomach sleepers will face a lot of difficulties finding the right mattress for themselves. They need a very firm mattress, and this one is just medium firm.

A Comprehensive Comparison of Tuft and Needle Vs. Tempurpedic Mattress features  

Construction

You will find the Tuft and Needle to be 10 inches tall. It is an all-foam mattress that consists of two different layers. In contrast, the Tempurpedic is a hybrid mattress that offers both foam and coils, giving you the ultimate comfort in 3 different layers.

The Tuft and Needle mattresses have a polyester blend fabric cover. It doesn’t affect the overall feel of the mattress but is thin and breathable. The first layer of the mattress is a comfort layer 3 inches thick. This proprietary material is poly foam, widely referred to as adaptive foam, and has unique characteristics. 

This layer of poly foam is infused with materials such as ceramic gel and graphite to help you sleep cool. These two combines to create a unique cooling technology that dissipates heat and counters the body heat that foam mattresses generally trap. Next, under this unique layer of proprietary poly foam, you get a high-density support foam that acts as a base layer for your mattress. 

The Tempurpedic, on the other hand, is not all-foam but a hybrid memory foam mattress. On the top, you get your breathable mattress cover that encourages air to flow through the mattress easily. 

Below the fabric cover, you get your top comfort layer that is made up of classic Tempur material. Unlike the Tuft and Needle, it does not have any cooling technology to counter the trapped body heat within the mattress. 

The Tempur material is a classic, slow-moving memory foam that lets you sink into the mattress slowly. You get another layer of support foam, or a transition foam made up of memory foam underneath. This one is much firmer than the top layer and adds to the overall firmness of the mattress too. Lastly, under these two layers, you have your main support layer of the mattress. This is where you get coils encased in a foam structure. These coils firm your bed and add a good combination of bounce and all that slow-moving memory foam. Lastly, at the bottom, you get a thin base layer of foam. 

Firmness

The Tuft and Needle use proprietary poly foam in it. This material mainly gives the mattress an overall bouncy feel. When we talk about firmness, the Tuft and Needle fall on a solid 6.5 on a scale of 10, with 10 being the highest. This means it has average firmness, but remember that how firm the mattress feels will significantly depend on your body size and weight. 

The mattress gives a balanced, firm feel because, on the top, the comfort layer initially gives you a soft sinking-in feeling – that’s what adaptive foam is great at. It gets its firmness from the layer below. Moving around this mattress is smooth, and you will not feel stuck in one place. 

In comparison, the Tempurpedic is not as bouncy as the Tuft and Needle because of its materials. This one is good for all those who love the classic slow-moving memory foam feel with almost no bounce. The two are entirely different in terms of feel. Firmness, however, is the same, 6.5/10. So, just an average firm mattress. The top layer has a slow sinking feeling to it. Once you lie down on the foam, it lets you sink in the softness. 

Motion Isolation and Edge Support

We know how vital motion isolation and edge support are while sleeping with a partner. You do not want to be disturbed every time your partner moves on the bed, especially if you are a light sleeper. The mattress companies take this very seriously and are constantly improving their motion isolation and edge support quality. 

Tests done by experts prove that the Tuft and Needle have excellent motion isolation properties. It exhibits low to no motion transfer, meaning you can sleep peacefully even if your partner moves around and does their thing on the bed. You will not be disturbed. Making it a good mattress for couples. The Tempurpedic also does a superb job in motion isolation. You will not feel a single movement of your partner. What more would you ask for? 

With motion support, you also need to be sure about edge support. Sleeping with a partner means sleeping towards the edge and not the middle. You should feel safe and secure on the edge of your mattress and not fear falling.

Sitting down on edge, you will notice that the Tuft and Needle collapses, making you feel like rolling off. Lying down on the edge of the mattress is a bit different. The mattress collapses a bit, but you still feel secure in one place and do not feel like you will fall off the bed. On the other hand, the Tempurpedic does more than an okay job with edge support. The mattress does collapse, but you stay firm while sitting or lying on the edge of the bed. The feeling, however, might be different for different body types. 

Temperature

The Tuft and Needle is a fantastic mattress that can be seen doing its best to counter all the heat that all-foam mattresses tend to trap. It is amazing at temperature regulation and helps you sleep cool throughout. The top comfort layer has infusions of ceramic gel and graphite that come together to give you a cool feel. These both are great at dissipating heat and maintaining body temperatures.

The Tempurpedic, on the other hand, has no such infusions. The temperature regulation system depends entirely on the breathable foam cover and the coils towards the end layer of the mattress. Keeping this in mind, it may not be the best mattress for hot sleepers. 

Sleeping Position and Body Type

One of the deciding factors in buying a mattress is knowing which mattress suits which body type the best. If you love sleeping on your back, you come under the category of back sleepers. And if that is the case, you will find this mattress to be an okay match for you, especially if you are 250 pounds plus in terms of your body height and weight. This is mainly due to the construction of the mattress. It is relatively a thinner mattress and will not be able to provide you with the firm support heavy sleepers generally need. 

Next, if you are a side sleeper, you will be surprised at how good this is at pressure relief. The adaptive foam on the top will feel soft and comfortable simultaneously, providing you with the right pressure relief your body needs as a side sleeper. Lastly, this is a no-go area for all stomach sleepers (check 10 amazing mattresses for stomach sleepers). Try sleeping on your stomach on this mattress, and you will feel your body going out of alignment. 

The Tempurpedic aligns your body well, gives you amazing lumbar support, and your hips sink in just the right amount. All are owing to the coils at the bottom paired with the memory foam on top. It is a good option for side sleepers too. Your hips and shoulders feel very comfortable, and the thick comfort layer on top gives you comfort like no other (check the top rated mattresses for shoulder pain). 

Price Range 

The Tuft and Needle mattresses are available in all sizes, from $745 to $1395 (check 10 top-quality mattresses under $1,000). This, compared to the Tempurpedic, seems to be very affordable. The Tempurpedic is available in all sizes, including a Split King. The price range starts at $ 1899 and goes up to a whopping $ 3798 (check 10 top-quality mattresses under 2,000 dollars). 

Both have good deals and packages available on their websites which you might want to consider. However, the Tuft and Needle still is the more economical option.  

	Tuft and Needle	Tempurpedic
Twin	$745	$ 1899
Twin XL	$ 795	$1899
Full	$ 895	$2099
Queen	$ 995	$2199
King	$ 1395	$2599
Cal King	$1395	$2599
Split King	–	$3798

Important Considerations When Choosing Between Tuft & Needle and Tempurpedic

When comparing Tuft & Needle and Tempurpedic mattresses, it’s important to consider the trial period and warranty of each. Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night trial period, while Tempurpedic has a 90-night sleep trial. This gives you a chance to test out the mattress in your own home before fully committing.

Both companies also provide 10-year limited warranties, covering defects in materials and manufacturing. However, Tempurpedic’s warranty is prorated after the first 10 years, meaning you’ll pay a percentage of the original price for a replacement. Tuft & Needle’s warranty remains fully valid for the entire 10 years. Make sure to read the fine print to understand exactly what’s covered. The trial period and warranty can give you confidence in your big mattress purchase.

Verdict:

So, we are hoping by now you must have a clearer picture of which mattress can provide you with the best you are looking for. The Tuft and Needle have it all. It focuses on keeping you cool and comfortable during your sleep. The only con is its thickness. So, it might not be the best choice for people weighing 250 pounds and more. Compared to this, the Tempurpedic has a lot to offer and is priced accordingly. In the end, what suits you most is what matters the most!